For years, we’ve been told that CNG (Compressed Natural Gas) is a clean and eco-friendly alternative to petrol and diesel. From taxis to buses and even private cars — CNG has gained massive popularity in India and other developing countries. But is it truly as clean as people believe?
Let’s uncover the truth behind this so-called “clean fuel” and separate facts from myths.
What Exactly Is CNG?
CNG stands for Compressed Natural Gas, which mainly consists of methane (CH₄) — a simple hydrocarbon. It’s stored under high pressure and used as a fuel in vehicles that have CNG kits installed.
Natural gas is extracted from the Earth, similar to crude oil, but it’s lighter and burns more efficiently.
When used in vehicles, CNG is known to produce:
- Fewer carbon emissions than petrol or diesel
- Almost no particulate matter (soot)
- Less carbon monoxide
This is why CNG vehicles are often promoted as “green” or “environment-friendly.”
Why CNG Is Considered a Clean Fuel
Let’s start with the positives — because there are several reasons why governments and carmakers support CNG adoption.
1. Lower Carbon Emissions
CNG emits about 20–25% less CO₂ compared to petrol. Since methane has a higher hydrogen content, it burns more completely, producing less carbon.
2. Reduced Air Pollutants
Unlike diesel, CNG combustion produces almost no particulate matter or black smoke. It also emits less nitrogen oxides (NOx), which cause smog and respiratory problems.
3. No Lead or Sulphur
CNG does not contain lead or sulphur compounds, both of which are toxic and harmful to human health and the environment.
4. Better Engine Life
CNG burns cleaner inside the engine, reducing deposits on pistons and valves. This can increase engine life and reduce maintenance costs.
5. Cost Efficiency
CNG is usually cheaper per kilometre than petrol or diesel. For daily commuters, it’s an economical option that also claims to be eco-friendly.
So far, it sounds great — cleaner, cheaper, and safer. But here’s where the myth part begins.
The Hidden Truth: Is CNG 100% Clean?
While CNG is cleaner than petrol or diesel, it is not completely clean. Let’s understand why it’s not the “perfect green fuel” many think it is.
1. Methane Leaks During Extraction and Transport
CNG’s main component, methane, is a powerful greenhouse gas — over 25 times more potent than CO₂ when it comes to trapping heat in the atmosphere.
During natural gas extraction, processing, and transportation, methane often leaks into the air. These fugitive emissions can offset the environmental benefits of using CNG in vehicles.
So even though your CNG car emits less CO₂, the overall climate impact (from well to wheel) may still be significant due to methane leakage.
2. CNG Is Still a Fossil Fuel
CNG may be “cleaner,” but it’s not renewable. It still comes from fossil resources. This means:
- It contributes to resource depletion
- It releases carbon when burned
- It cannot be a long-term sustainable solution
Compared to electric or hydrogen-based vehicles, CNG is only a temporary bridge fuel — not the future of clean mobility.
3. CO₂ Is Still Emitted
Even with lower emissions, CNG still produces carbon dioxide. For every kilogram of CNG burned, around 2.75 kg of CO₂ is released. That’s lower than diesel, but it’s not zero.
If the world truly wants carbon neutrality, then reducing CO₂ to near zero is the goal — and CNG can’t achieve that.
4. Not Suitable for All Engines
CNG engines may face issues such as:
- Lower power output compared to petrol
- Valve wear due to dry combustion
- Limited refuelling stations in some areas
These technical challenges make CNG less practical for heavy vehicles or long-distance driving.
5. Indirect Energy Use and Production Emissions
To compress, store, and transport CNG, electricity and energy are required. If that electricity comes from coal-based power plants, the indirect emissions increase further — reducing its “clean” advantage.
CNG vs Electric Vehicles (EVs): Which Is Cleaner?
Here’s a quick comparison:
| Feature | CNG Vehicles | Electric Vehicles (EVs) |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Fossil fuel (natural gas) | Renewable or grid electricity |
| CO₂ Emission (tailpipe) | Low | Zero |
| Methane Impact | High (leakage risk) | None |
| Maintenance | Low | Very low |
| Fuel Refill Time | Fast | Slower |
| Sustainability | Medium | High (with green power) |
So while CNG is cleaner than petrol or diesel, EVs are still far ahead in terms of overall environmental impact — especially if powered by renewable energy.
Government Push and Real-World Impact
In India, cities like Delhi, Mumbai, and Ahmedabad have promoted CNG buses and taxis to reduce smog and improve air quality. This move has indeed lowered visible smoke and particulate pollution.
However, experts say that urban air pollution reduction doesn’t necessarily mean climate pollution reduction. CNG may improve local air, but methane emissions contribute globally to climate warming.
Hence, calling it a completely clean fuel is partially true — it’s cleaner, but not clean.
The Future: Renewable Natural Gas (RNG)
The future may lie in Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) — also called biomethane. It’s produced from organic waste like:
- Agricultural residue
- Landfill gas
- Sewage waste
RNG has the same chemical makeup as CNG but comes from renewable sources, meaning it can reduce net greenhouse gas emissions significantly.
Countries like Sweden and the US are already using biogas-based CNG for vehicles. If India invests in similar technologies, “green CNG” could truly become clean.
Final Verdict: Myth or Reality?
CNG is cleaner than petrol and diesel.
CNG is not a completely clean or green fuel.
It’s a transitional energy source, helpful in reducing urban air pollution and cutting fuel costs. But due to methane leaks, fossil dependency, and CO₂ emissions, it cannot be considered a long-term clean solution.
The real future of clean transport lies in:
- Electric mobility
- Hydrogen fuel
- Bio-CNG and renewable gases
Conclusion
CNG is a smart step towards reducing pollution, but it’s not the final step. The belief that it’s “100% clean” is a myth — the truth lies in understanding its limitations and improving technology to make it cleaner.
So, the next time someone says “CNG is a clean fuel,” you’ll know the complete story behind it.
good